I don't envy the choice the judges have to make between this entry and Stejk's. I think i'll give my compare/contrast in this review:
'Chicken Castle'
- The idea feels more complete compared to the other short... a clear beginning middle and end, simple story that flows as it should. I feel the pacing and general shift between the various phases of the Chicken Castle short (especially the beginning) are substantially better than Stejk's entry. Maybe just my opinion but that's my thoughts on it.
- I like how you seemed to purposely use your style against the "NATA theme", then reveal the protagonist as the central point to link to its relevance. The idea of using your style as the "antagonist" puts some really fun irony in the mix!
'Animate in Your Opponent'
- I feel Stejk did a better job of capturing the look and feel of the "opponent style" and I'd personally yield more points for that judgement category. In terms of adaptability, I feel this short came out on top.
- While Butzbo's "style" is already known for its creative, whacky, unique visuals, Stejk's short was complimented with well-balanced lighting, smart camera work, and quality drawings. I actually thought I was watching a Butzbo production when I first played the file. I can easily see this short earning extra points for raw skill and adaptability.
In any case, you guys worked hard and rocked it in NATA!